The Trump administration is asking a federal judge to dismiss a lawsuit filed by the Navajo Nation alleging the government failed to protect the tribe’s water rights in the Colorado River. The lawsuit, initiated in 2003 and amended numerous times, claims the federal government breached its trust responsibility to the Navajo Nation by not securing the tribe’s fair share of the river’s water. The Nation argues this failure has significantly harmed the tribe’s economic development, health, and well-being.
The government contends the Navajo Nation’s claims are too broad, lack specificity regarding damages, and attempt to relitigate issues already decided in previous settlements and legal actions related to the Colorado River. They argue that the tribe hasn’t clearly demonstrated how specific federal actions directly caused harm or how they violated a specific trust duty.
The government further asserts that the Navajo Nation’s claims are barred by the statute of limitations and that the tribe has not properly exhausted all administrative remedies. The Justice Department lawyers representing the U.S. argue that the court should defer to Congress and the executive branch regarding the allocation and management of the Colorado River’s resources, citing complex interstate agreements and federal legislation governing the river. The Navajo Nation views the lawsuit as critical to securing their water future in the face of increasing drought and climate change impacting the Colorado River Basin.
find the original article here: https://www.yahoo.com/news/trump-administration-asks-judge-toss-224422284.html